Knowing and Seeing
«absorbing . . . extraordinarily rich . . . I hope enough has been said to give a sense of the major accomplishment that Knowing and Seeing represents, and of the major benefits contemporary epistemology stands to reap from taking it seriously.»
Johannes Roessler, Mind
What is knowledge? What, if anything, can we know? In Knowing and Seeing, Michael Ayers recovers the insight in the traditional distinction between knowledge and belief, according to which 'knowledge' stems from direct and perspicuous cognitive contact with ('seeing') its object, whereas 'belief' relies on 'extraneous' justification. Les mer
of which is not only direct realism, but recognition that in being perceptually aware of anything we are at the same time perceptually aware of how we are aware of it. Perceptual knowing comes with knowing how you know. Some other forms of knowledge are similarly direct and perspicuous, but not all; a
distinction is accordingly drawn between primary and secondary knowledge, and Ayers argues that no secondary knowledge is possible without some primary knowledge. Perceptual knowledge supplies the paradigm to which other cases of knowledge are diversely analogous - hence the notorious difficulty of defining knowledge. These conclusions, supported by a detailed examination of the relations between different grammatical constructions in which 'know', 'believe' and 'see' occur, fuel extended
critiques of two lines of thought influential in contemporary epistemology: John McDowell's conceptualist and intellectualist account of perceptual knowledge, and Fred Dretske's 'externalist' employment of sceptical argument. Ayers unpicks the arguments for these other views, explains the failure of
recent attempts at a comprehensive definition of knowledge, explores the tight relation between knowledge and certainty, and gives an account of how 'defeasibility' should and should not be understood in epistemology.
Detaljer
- Forlag
- Oxford University Press
- Innbinding
- Innbundet
- Språk
- Engelsk
- ISBN
- 9780198833567
- Utgivelsesår
- 2019
- Format
- 14 x 16 cm
Anmeldelser
«absorbing . . . extraordinarily rich . . . I hope enough has been said to give a sense of the major accomplishment that Knowing and Seeing represents, and of the major benefits contemporary epistemology stands to reap from taking it seriously.»
Johannes Roessler, Mind
«immensely rich and inspiring»
Naomi Osorio-Kupferblum and Mira Magdalena Sickinger, Grazer Philosophische Studien
«Ayers's book contains a wealth of claims and arguments of interest to epistemologists and philosophers of mind»
Simon Wimmer, Zeitschrift für philosophische Literatur