«

Extremely well researched and well explained,
alternating explanation of concepts and application
of these concepts to many diverse examples, the
volume mixes some well-known authors with
others much less famous (and actually many out of print) and still others simply unknown (at least new to
me). This is the best book one can write about comics. [...] The cherry on the French cake [or if you don’t like cakes, the dressing on the fresh mixed salad]: as usual,
this publisher (Leuven U.P.) provides high quality paper and binding, and beautiful reproductions of
pictures, some in color, and in this case also a full precise index of 20p. and an extraordinary rich and
diverse bibliography of 35p. What else can a humanist fan scholar could wish for? Again, this is the type of
books that we see once a decade.Christian Reyns-Chikuma, IMAGE [&] NARRATIVE Vol. 22, No.3 (2021)

»

«

Dans une analyse nuancée, McKinney démontre comment les artistes « ont redessiné l’histoire et la culture impériale pour représenter la France postcoloniale », et ce « de nombreuses manières, et parfois contradictoires » . Il génère des pistes d’analyse pertinentes, en adaptant des concepts formels à une analyse socio-littéraire autour du postcolonial et de la migration. Sa conclusion invite, par ailleurs, à réfléchir au paradigme du postcolonial, et à la possibilité de l’étendre à de nouvelles formes néocoloniales (continuation de l’exploitation impérialiste, tourisme occidental en Afrique, soutien de régimes autoritaires, migrations climatiques…). [...] Cet ouvrage prouve, néanmoins, l’immensité d’un champ de recherche qui permet de mieux comprendre les représentations d’une société postcoloniale interculturelle, et l’urgence de l’étudier.Alicia Lambert, French Studies in Southern Africa No. 52 (2022): 194-250

»

«

Bandes dessinées and graphic novels are essential texts in university French courses, and McKinney’s insightful study is a welcome addition to the critical literature on these works. His book traces the shifting portrayals of migration and transculturation in postcolonial France. [...] This expansive and erudite study of BD shows how the genre creates new spaces for representation and dialogue on postcolonial migration in France.Patricia Geesey,The French Review, vol. 96 no. 1, 2022, p. 202-202, doi:10.1353/tfr.2022.0182

»

«

Along with McKinney’s previous publications, the present monograph is the fruit of nearly three
decades of research. As such, 'Postcolonialism and Migration in French Comics' makes several
noteworthy contributions to the field. Among its many positive aspects, this study refers to wellknown and previously un(der)studied works; identifies areas of further inquiry such as the
developing role of female artists; provides a well-documented historical context that draws
important parallels between French (post)colonial history and the evolution of French comics;
and establishes a constructive dialogue between the author’s own research and that of recognized
experts and emerging scholars. Not only does McKinney trace the history of postcolonial themes
in French comics, but he also provides a summative overview of past and current scholarship,
which will undoubtedly serve undergraduates, graduates, and academics in future years.Jennifer Howell, H-France Review, vol. 21, no. 168, September 2021

»